Where can you find the BEST Italian-American food in Brooklyn? Danielle Caminiti—AKA ‪@HaveUCoveredIntheKitchen‬—recommends Bamonte's, located at 32 Withers Street in Williamsburg. Bamonte's has been owned and operated by the same family for a staggering 125 years, making it the oldest Italian restaurant in Brooklyn. Bamonte's does all of the red sauce classics exceptionally well, but their claim to fame is having purportedly invented the dish chicken parmigiana.